Gender Diversity

GenderDiversityBanner-11.png

The Gender Diversity toolkit was developed by Katelyn Burns and includes the following: an introductory overview, a list of key terms and definitions, a list of experts on the subject, links to additional resources on the topic, an accompanying presentation, and activity worksheets.

Created by Katelyn Burns for Equality for HER

Table of Contents


Visual Guide

Background

Gender diverse people have existed throughout history. Anthropologists have uncovered cultures who have created space for gender diverse people on every inhabitable continent, including two spirit people in various Native American cultures as well as the Hijra on the Indian subcontinent. The modern interpretation that “there are only two genders” is a relatively recent historical gender philosophy stemming from western biblical notions of sex and gender from the major Abrahamic religions. As such the marginalization of gender diverse people cannot be separated from the history of western colonization.

The origins of more modern trans existence can be traced to Dr. Magnus Hirschfeld, a German doctor who pioneered the technique for modern Genital Reassignment Surgery for trans women still in use today. Hirschfield also recorded extensive notes on transgender and LGBTQ health care and advocacy at the Institut für Sexualwissenschaft (Institute of Sexual Research), which he founded in 1919. His entire Berlin work library was destroyed by a Nazi-aligned mob, infamously recorded in photographs of a massive Nazi book burning.

In the US, crossdressing was illegal until the early 1970’s in many places. The law stated that you must wear a certain number of articles of clothing that corresponded to your birth sex and it was these laws that police would use as cover to raid queer bars and arrest LGBTQ people. The Cafeteria Riots in San Francisco in 1967 were an early stand against these raids that were brought full circle at Stonewall. There a group of trans women of color, drag queens, and lesbians finally took a stand and fought back, forcing police to barricade themselves inside the bar. Every year since the queer community commemorates Stonewall with Pride parades in cities around the world.

Since the 1960’s progress for trans people within western society has been slow but steady and Time Magazine declared a transgender tipping point in 2014, featuring actress and trans woman Laverne Cox on their cover. However, along with increased media attention has come an intense backlash from religious conservatives and radical feminists. Suddenly legislative bills controlling where trans people could use the restroom were introduced across the United States. Additionally, transantagonistic activists have sought to cut off access to transition health care and legal support as well as to remove autonomy from transgender children to access puberty-delaying treatments.

Overview

Gender diverse people currently face many challenges on many fronts. In many countries, it’s still punishable by death to openly defy social gender expectations, while in others trans people are forced into conversion therapy designed to change their innate gender identity. Additionally, there is a global epidemic of violence directed at trans women, who often need to resort to sex work in order to survive.

The most basic change that would help trans women globally is the ability to quickly and seamlessly change the gender and name on their official government ID documents. Without updated IDs, finding regular employment becomes impossible, since the ID itself outs their trans status to employers who might be transphobic. As a result, trans women are forced to either find a boyfriend or partner who will financially support them, or turn to sex work, it’s just simple economics. Another policy change that would help trans women globally would be open borders. With the ability to move to a country that will recognize their transitions and allow document changes, trans women would then be able to pursue careers other than sex work, should they so choose. Though trans rights in western Europe and the United States have made significant progress since the days when crossdressing was illegal, issues are currently in a state of flux as well.

In the UK, trans people are fighting for an updated Gender Recognition Act, which would allow easier access to changing genders on official government IDs. Debate on the act, however, has kicked off a national moral panic, spearheaded by transphobic radical feminists and their allies in the media.

In the US, trans people face a multitude of issues. Currently, 4 states forbid gender changes on birth certificates entirely, while many others require expensive and invasive surgeries like GRS to be able to change IDs. This dynamic, coupled with a lack of legal housing and employment protections, can leave trans people’s fortunes in the hands of a systemically transphobic housing and employment sector.

As a result, trans people are three times more likely to be unemployed than the general population and are especially at risk for homelessness. Adding in even more intersecting marginalizations makes this situation even worse, with trans women of color suffering worse systemic outcomes, generally.

Historically, transition health care has been mostly inaccessible to many trans people. In 1981, radical feminists partnered with religious conservatives to remove transition coverage from Medicare, and private insurance followed suit. It wasn’t until Obamacare Rule 1557 banning discrimination on the basis of gender identity that private insurance companies and Medicare began offering coverage for procedures like GRS again, a gap of over 25 years. As a result, trans people were forced into funding procedures with their own funds, which again funneled trans women into sex work in order to access the care they needed. Access to transgender health care is absolutely critical for the trans community.

Regardless of the specific issues facing specific trans people, the overarching problem is cisgender society simply doesn’t believe trans people when we define our own gender for ourselves. Just as it was then, forcing trans people into their birth assigned gender in order to access normalcy within society is an act of colonialism. The urge to coerce or define the gender of another person should be resisted at all costs, for gender is an individual matter for everyone and isn’t up for debate.

Terms & Definitions

Language to describe gender can be very personal and important for gender diverse people. It’s also key to understand that trans specific language is constantly changing within the trans community and the best policy is to trust us to define the language that describes our lives and experiences with gender.

Download Gender Diversity Terms

Download Gender Diversity Terms in Open Dyslexic Font

transgender - always an adjective used to describe people whose gender identity doesn’t align with their assigned sex at birth. Never use as a noun, for example “the transgenders were banned from the military” should read “transgender people were banned from the military”.

cisgender - an adjective used to describe people whose gender identities match their assigned sex at birth. The term is Latin and derives from modern chemistry as the opposite of “trans”, meaning “on the same side”. Cisgender or cis is not a slur and is often confused with straight or heterosexual. Cisgender as a term has no relation to sexuality as straight trans people also exist.

transsexual - a term which has fallen out of favor within the trans community, though some trans people still use it an identifier to signal that their relation to gender is heavily based on sex or genital physical dysphoria.

non-binary - an adjective to describe the gender identity of people who fall somewhere in between the masculine and feminine ends of the gender identity spectrum or are completely outside of the gender binary or identify as neither man nor woman.

genderqueer - a term some trans people use to describe themselves. Generally genderqueer people strive to incorporate elements of masculinity and femininity together within their gender expression.

gender dysphoria - a clinical term representing the distress felt by someone whose internal sense of their own gender is in conflict with their outwardly visible gender markers

transphobia - an intense dislike or revulsion towards the existence of trans people. It mainly manifests as a denial of trans autonomy to define our own genders “IE trans women are really men, etc”.

Transmisia - a newer term similar to “transphobia” that seeks to destigmatize people with clinically diagnosed phobias.

transmisogyny - a term to describe the unique way that society discriminates against trans women for being women with sexism, while also fundamentally denying their womanhood by branding them “really men”.

transition - the term used to describe the process in which trans people seek to change their gender or gender expression. Often but not necessarily involving medical treatment, a name change, and/or pronoun changes.

Important to note that there should always be a space between trans and man/woman. Trans is short for transgender and you wouldn’t write “transgenderwoman” so “transwoman” wouldn’t make sense either. The “transwoman” moniker was invented by transphobic feminists to force trans women into a third sex category separate from womanhood.

trans woman - a term to describe someone who was assigned male at birth who has transitioned to female. Rule of thumb: Always attach the trans modifier to a trans person’s destination gender.

trans man - a term to describe someone who was assigned female at birth who transitioned to male.

assigned [sex] at birth - rather than saying “born male/female” trans people refer to their sex as having been assigned to them by people other than themselves. Birth sex assignments aren’t simply the doctor’s observation at birth but can also refer to the way trans people are systemically forced into socialization based on their birth assigned sex. Often expressed with “AMAB” or “AFAB”.

pronouns - including this to note that “preferred pronouns” indicates that trans people’s pronouns are optional, they are not. Trans people’s pronouns are just as valid as cisgender people’s pronouns. They’re not preferred or optional, they are mandatory.

drag queen - a person who dons a cross-gender costume for performance purposes. Some drag queens are also trans, but the two terms should not be conflated.

transvestite/  crossdresser - generally used to describe people who have male gender identities who dress in traditionally female clothes, sometimes for sexual gratification. Some trans people may start their gender exploration with crossdressing, but the two terms should not be conflated.

transfeminine/transmasculine - an adjective to describe a broader spectrum of trans identities. Transfeminine or transfemme people are usually AMAB and now express their genders on the feminine side of the gender spectrum and vice versa for transmasculine/transmasc people.

Genital Reconstruction Surgery - often shortened to GRS, this term describes surgeries designed to change the genitals of a trans person. Formerly referred to as “sex change surgery”, this procedure has gone through several terms and is constantly in flux. AKA gender confirmation surgery (GCS), bottom surgery, sex reassignment surgery (SRS).

T.E.R.F. or TERF - an acronym for Trans Exclusionary Radical Feminist. TERFs believe that gender is completely socially induced and that trans women specifically are men who appropriate the female body for themselves. The term TERF is an accurate, neutral representation of this ideology and is not a slur.

People

Please note this list is woefully incomplete and put together with diversity of marginalization, experience, and age in mind. There is no one true trans experience, but these folx on this list are people that are putting in the work or have put in a lot of work in advocating for gender diverse people and their issues.

Add your own suggestions in the comments below!

  • Laverne Cox - actress she/her
  • Paris Lees - UK based journalist/campaigner she/her
  • Kate Bornstein - author/activist they/them
  • Mitch Kellaway - writer he/him
  • Jenny Boylan - writer she/her
  • Raquel Willis - writer/advocate she/her
  • Fox Fisher - activist they/them
  • Julia Serano - writer she/her
  • J Mase III - Poet/educator he/him
  • Sarah McBride - advocate/author she/her
  • Jennifer Levi - attorney she/they/he
  • Esperanz Maríe Aguilera Fuentes - YouTuber/Educator she/they

Resources & Discussion Questions

The following list of resources and discussion questions on the subject of Gender Diversity:

Whipping Girl - Julia Serano - A book which helped establish the basic concepts of transfeminism.

  • When examining transmisogynistic discourse, how is femininity itself degraded and scapegoated in the process?
  • How does oppositional sexism contribute to transmisogyny and transphobia?

The Left’s Long History of Transphobia - The Establishment

  • Sometimes it’s easy to imagine each side of the political spectrum as completely righteous or completely evil, depending upon your own political views. However, with larger systemic bigotries, it’s rarely clear cut. How can those on the political left start countering transphobic arguments from within.

A Map of Gender Diverse Cultures - PBS

  • Looking at this map, what was your initial reaction to seeing that historically there has been at least one gender diverse culture on every inhabitable continent?

  • After seeing the map, how can you incorporate gender diversity into your own efforts to deconstruct colonialism?

Sex redefined - Nature - A breakdown of the science supporting the fact that gender is a spectrum

  • What are a few ways in which people’s gender can end up outside of the sexed, genetic binary of male and female?

  • Why is it so important for scientists to explore the murky edges of the defining line between male and female and what does that uncertainty say about commonly held notions of differences between male and female behavior?

I Am Genderqueer (And What the #@%! That Means) - Contrapoints - A very accessible and humorous YouTube video that does a great job explaining a lot of the basic conce pts for non-binary and genderqueer identities.

  • Contrapoints brings up the fact that in the past she has often invoked femme men as objects of ridicule and disgust, and brings up Rocky Horror and Silence of the Lambs. This depiction is a common popular culture trope, name 3 other movies or TV shows that sought to create a disgusted reaction to transfeminine bodies from the viewing audience.
  • Contrapoints goes to great lengths to try to counter the commonly held social notions that marginalize genderqueer identities. Why are people generally so resistant to the idea that someone could be neither male or female, or both, or somewhere in between?

Worksheets

Coming Soon...

Katelyn BurnsComment